AEA AEA SF .30 another "talk me out of"

After the Gauntlet conversation yesterday you guys were nice enough to talk me out of that rifle. So I started my search over again. The AEA SF is lighter but still has a bottle that can be upgraded and allows for 4500 PSI. It can be used as a bolt action. It looks better (to me) and it comes in three barrel lengths. Searching the threads on here the only complaint seems to be a heavy trigger and I can live with that. What do you guys think?
 
If it were me, 1st thing I'd do is weigh the number of negative commentaries here vs the positive on AEA stuff. I've never held or shot an AEA gun but in my memory, from posts here, the bad outweighs the good. But that's me. YMMV.

Good council.

I own a bunch of AEA guns but airsmithing has allowed me to understand and correct issues others would/could discourage.

My Challenger Big 9mm makes 300 fpe, it hits 2MOA, perfect 50y deer gun.
 
I'd pass unless you are capable of replacing poppets.

I have the HP Semi Auto in 22.
The old or the new? The old ones sucked.
After the Gauntlet conversation yesterday you guys were nice enough to talk me out of that rifle. So I started my search over again. The AEA SF is lighter but still has a bottle that can be upgraded and allows for 4500 PSI. It can be used as a bolt action. It looks better (to me) and it comes in three barrel lengths. Searching the threads on here the only complaint seems to be a heavy trigger and I can live with that. What do you guys think?
The semi's have always had problems, more so the older models.

For a more reliable AEA platform get yourself a bolt action or side lever. I had a Varmint .25 thay was robust. All the other AEA semis either the poppets broke, they pushed so much air to cycle the next round that it pushed the round past the mag to the back cause it to lodge itself in the block or it would cause the clear face to break off infront of your face.
 
I won't buy from Umarex. Bought a $329 Origin 18 months ago. Found out I could not find O ring and rebuild kits for it anywhere.
Called Umarex.
Umarex told me it was discontinued. And basically tough luck on an O ring kit.
The point I am making here is to not so much look at the newest fluff. But to look for a company you feel confident in should issues arise.
I would call and E mail companies on tht you are interested in and ask or find out online if rebuild kits are available?
I invested over $550 in Umarex and felt a bad vibe when I called them 5 days ago.
Research the company first and make sure O rings and all rubber parts are easily replaceable.
Cry once buy once.
Find a reputable company with available after market parts.
Or do like me and purchase 3 Umarex Zada *EDITED* HATSAN in .25 since those are budget priced. Each one around $124.
One goes out grab the new one.
Sorry, I am rambling too much.
Just don't want to see you make a mistake like I did. And purchase something you can't get parts for.
 
Last edited:
The old or the new? The old ones sucked.

The semi's have always had problems, more so the older models.

For a more reliable AEA platform get yourself a bolt action or side lever. I had a Varmint .25 thay was robust. All the other AEA semis either the poppets broke, they pushed so much air to cycle the next round that it pushed the round past the mag to the back cause it to lodge itself in the block or it would cause the clear face to break off infront of your face.

Yupper, that's mine!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JaceSpace1369
I won't buy from Umarex. Bought a $329 Origin 18 months ago. Found out I could not find O ring and rebuild kits for it anywhere.
Called Umarex.
Umarex told me it was discontinued. And basically tough luck on an O ring kit.
The point I am making here is to not so much look at the newest fluff. But to look for a company you feel confident in should issues arise.
I would call and E mail companies on tht you are interested in and ask or find out online if rebuild kits are available?
I invested over $550 in Umarex and felt a bad vibe when I called them 5 days ago.
Research the company first and make sure O rings and all rubber parts are easily replaceable.
Cry once buy once.
Find a reputable company with available after market parts.
Or do like me and purchase 3 Umarex Zada in .25 since those are budget priced. Each one around $124.
One goes out grab the new one.
Sorry, I am rambling too much.
Just don't want to see you make a mistake like I did. And purchase something you can't get parts for.
For what it's worth, I'm sorry for your issue with umarex.



The website is a reliable place to get spare parts for EVERY known manufacturer.
 
I have the .25 Varmint, great gun! Lightweight and powerful!
The one I had, I sold it to one of the guys I took on an iguana hunting tour, he rocked them so well with that gun he asked if he could buy it from me. That became his first pcp haha. I liked shooting it, just didn't like how long it was. Also liked that it didnt need a moderator.
 
The one I had, I sold it to one of the guys I took on an iguana hunting tour, he rocked them so well with that gun he asked if he could buy it from me. That became his first pcp haha. I liked shooting it, just didn't like how long it was. Also liked that it didnt need a moderator.

Mine goes in the classifieds in the next few weeks, It's fantastic but other guns have taken the throne and I want to pair down my collection.

GREAT GUN!
 
For what it's worth, I'm sorry for your issue with umarex.



The website is a reliable place to get spare parts for EVERY known manufacturer.
I did not know that until now. I gave it to a Good red head Irish man so he could teach himself and his kiid safe shooting skills for beginners.
So I am pretty happy to know I may have turned someone on to air rifle shooting.
I pretty much am of the sound mind that if I get an air rifle. I want a single shot pcp .50 cal for medium to big game.
And that will cost. And is a future plan.
For now I am going to buy anoother budget cheap spare Hatsan Zada design since I love the solid stock build quality.
I am of the mind I am better off if I can afford a $600 pcp or a $400 range on up middle class break barrel.
That I can maintain easier with less company hassle than with some PCP's
 
For what it's worth, I'm sorry for your issue with umarex.



The website is a reliable place to get spare parts for EVERY known manufacturer.
One day I will buy off Umarex again. I like their Gauntlet ll in .30 and .35.
Hard to stay mad for too long.
Some of Umarex's stuff is top notch. (y)(y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: JaceSpace1369
Mine goes in the classifieds in the next few weeks, It's fantastic but other guns have taken the throne and I want to pair down my collection.

GREAT GUN!
Nicee! I can never keep too many guns or the same gun for long enough I wouod be what you call a trade-a-holic or I guess a tradesman? Lol
 
One day I will buy off Umarex again. I like their Gauntlet ll in .30 and .35.
Hard to stay mad for too long.
Some of Umarex's stuff is top notch. (y)(y)
That macavity arms 2 30 long is calling my name. I just need to know if it makes more power than the standard, they both state 81fpe on pyramidair