Other Death of the springer

A Quattro? Really?

Awesome!

I'll take it! PM me and we'll figure it out.
20241205_210607.jpg
 
My point exactly.

I'm in the Rio Grande valley at 4000 fas. The mountain peaks 12 miles away are 9000 fas. It's not high elevation compared to Lima, Peru. But its a lot higher than most places in the US. All my shooting so far has been at 4000 fas. Just north of El Paso Texas on your Rand McNally road atlas.

It still does not account for a 100 fps drop over a thousand shots at the same altitude.

The D34, a truckload of hatsans and 2 Cometas seem to shoot just fine for big happy long time. It's only the HW rifles (4 HW95 and one HW97k) that I could fart a pellet faster. Brand new out of the box they shot fine but they all gassed out fast.

My oldest Hatsan finally broke the third warranty repair trigger. It has probably 20k shots in its 18 month lifespan. It shoots 765 fps and about an 1.5" CTC at 50 yards. It cost me a whopping $129. I'll put a used trigger in it and it will probably outlast a new factory HW.

Even after the Vortek kit the HW95 is about 650. The second rebuild (AOA) on the 97k it was the same. That's plenty fast. I honestly don't care how fast they shoot if their accurate. And they are. They just break springs and slow down after a few shots and then slowly decline.

I'm honestly tired of sending them back and tearing them apart to replace the splintered springs. Same with buying a new gun and having to send every one back time after time. And I'm not about to drop $575 on another new gun I have to tear apart and stuff another $125 into to get it to shoot. I'd rather miss every third shot than bend over and get that reach around again.

I'll rebuild the 97k simply because I've got a pile invested in it already. If I can't get it to stabilize 650+ for a couple thousand shots you'll see both my HW's in the for sale thread.

I don't mind working on a rifle to fix it. But I'm not about to keep pumping cash in a money pit. Especially one I can't shoot 50 yards without cranking the rear sight higher.

I can get a new Tikka T3 in 30-06 that will shoot 3" @ 500 yards for about what i have invested in the HW97k. I can shoot it for 12-15k shots before it's over 1 moa. Then another 10k before it needs rebarreling. All I need is an 8 lb. can of XMR4350 and I'm set for a couple years.
I live at 9,000' ASL. I'm taking ~24% hit on published FPS for our ProSport.

Published numbers for an HW95N on AOA says 700 FPS for .22 cal.

So, adjusting for your 4,000' ASL, if I ran the numbers right, you should be getting ~606.7 FPS out of your 95. Based on practical experience. Not scientific or mathematical whatever.

So, yes, you're results are a little low; but not terribly low.

And yes, our ProSport dropped significant FPS after we used it a while, too.

This is not really what this thread was intended to talk about, but I hope it helps.

And I'm with you on most of what you've said. If I had known about Cometa's, and had they been available in early October 2023 when I went shopping for something to replace our zitrone HW97K, I think I would have bought a Cometa, and I don't think I would have been terribly disappointed in it for a fraction of the cost of the ProSport. I like nice things, but $1K for an air rifle that you have to finish the stock yourself is a bit insane, in my opinion. We *needed* something, though, and I wasn't about to buy another HW.

Anyway, cheers...
 
My point exactly.

I'm in the Rio Grande valley at 4000 fas. The mountain peaks 12 miles away are 9000 fas. It's not high elevation compared to Lima, Peru. But its a lot higher than most places in the US. All my shooting so far has been at 4000 fas. Just north of El Paso Texas on your Rand McNally road atlas.

It still does not account for a 100 fps drop over a thousand shots at the same altitude.

The D34, a truckload of hatsans and 2 Cometas seem to shoot just fine for big happy long time. It's only the HW rifles (4 HW95 and one HW97k) that I could fart a pellet faster. Brand new out of the box they shot fine but they all gassed out fast.

My oldest Hatsan finally broke the third warranty repair trigger. It has probably 20k shots in its 18 month lifespan. It shoots 765 fps and about an 1.5" CTC at 50 yards. It cost me a whopping $129. I'll put a used trigger in it and it will probably outlast a new factory HW.

Even after the Vortek kit the HW95 is about 650. The second rebuild (AOA) on the 97k it was the same. That's plenty fast. I honestly don't care how fast they shoot if their accurate. And they are. They just break springs and slow down after a few shots and then slowly decline.

I'm honestly tired of sending them back and tearing them apart to replace the splintered springs. Same with buying a new gun and having to send every one back time after time. And I'm not about to drop $575 on another new gun I have to tear apart and stuff another $125 into to get it to shoot. I'd rather miss every third shot than bend over and get that reach around again.

I'll rebuild the 97k simply because I've got a pile invested in it already. If I can't get it to stabilize 650+ for a couple thousand shots you'll see both my HW's in the for sale thread.

I don't mind working on a rifle to fix it. But I'm not about to keep pumping cash in a money pit. Especially one I can't shoot 50 yards without cranking the rear sight higher.

I can get a new Tikka T3 in 30-06 that will shoot 3" @ 500 yards for about what i have invested in the HW97k. I can shoot it for 12-15k shots before it's over 1 moa. Then another 10k before it needs rebarreling. All I need is an 8 lb. can of XMR4350 and I'm set for a couple years.


The loss of velocity problem with factory HW springs is something that I have read about here before. A few years ago, there were also a lot of reports about this happening with Vortek kits. Those anecdotes are less frequent today, but for a while many reported this problem. My hw97k and one R7 both lost about 2fpe and 1fpe respectively within a thousand shots after installing a new Vortek kit (with seal). Some speculated that this was the result of both HW and Vortek seeking to maximize power in their choice of spring diameter and length. The overly stressing springs start strong, but sag a bit or even break after a thousand shots or so. ARH spring design seems to optimize shot cycle quality over power, and in my experience they have had far better longevity. Still requires that you spend $$$ to mod a basically new gun. But when I calculate cost per hour of enjoyment, even expensive spring guns are far ahead of other options. ☝️
R
 
I have an airgun channel on YouTube devoted to springers, or should I say, piston powered airguns. I believe that my channel analytics can help to explain the drop in production of fine spring powered guns. When looking at the age groups who subscribe to my channel it looks like this:

18 - 24 years old 4.5%
25 - 34 years old 10.2%
35 - 44 years old 16.0%
45 - 54 years old 16.9%
55 - 64 years old 26.3%
65 - and older 26.1%

So, as you can see, we ole' timers are what's keepin' the springers alive. When we're gone, I'm afraid that the piston guns will all but die with us.


 
I'm in the Rio Grande valley at 4000 fas. ...
I woke up this morning with the thought that I did the math wrong last night. I calculated you should be taking a 13.333% hit in velocity. That should be 10.67%, for 625.31 FPS if you are to be getting results similar to mine.

Please forgive me. I haven't been feeling so great lately.
 
Last edited:
I have an airgun channel on YouTube devoted to springers, or should I say, piston powered airguns. I believe that my channel analytics can help to explain the drop in production of fine spring powered guns. When looking at the age groups who subscribe to my channel it looks like this:

18 - 24 years old 4.5%
25 - 34 years old 10.2%
35 - 44 years old 16.0%
45 - 54 years old 16.9%
55 - 64 years old 26.3%
65 - and older 26.1%

So, as you can see, we ole' timers are what's keepin' the springers alive. When we're gone, I'm afraid that the piston guns will all but die with us.


Yeah. We old folks remember a simpler time, and miss it. Kids these days have never experienced that. All they know is the craziness we all live in today.
 
2
I have an airgun channel on YouTube devoted to springers, or should I say, piston powered airguns. I believe that my channel analytics can help to explain the drop in production of fine spring powered guns. When looking at the age groups who subscribe to my channel it looks like this:

18 - 24 years old 4.5%
25 - 34 years old 10.2%
35 - 44 years old 16.0%
45 - 54 years old 16.9%
55 - 64 years old 26.3%
65 - and older 26.1%

So, as you can see, we ole' timers are what's keepin' the springers alive. When we're gone, I'm afraid that the piston guns will all but die with us.


I think the alternative explanation is that airguns are somewhat of an old man’s hobby and that as many younger shooters age they will become more interested in airguns.

PCPs are definitely winning a big part of the airgun market at the expense of springers though.
 
The loss of velocity problem with factory HW springs is something that I have read about here before. A few years ago, there were also a lot of reports about this happening with Vortek kits. Those anecdotes are less frequent today, but for a while many reported this problem. My hw97k and one R7 both lost about 2fpe and 1fpe respectively within a thousand shots after installing a new Vortek kit (with seal). Some speculated that this was the result of both HW and Vortek seeking to maximize power in their choice of spring diameter and length. The overly stressing springs start strong, but sag a bit or even break after a thousand shots or so. ARH spring design seems to optimize shot cycle quality over power, and in my experience they have had far better longevity. Still requires that you spend $$$ to mod a basically new gun. But when I calculate cost per hour of enjoyment, even expensive spring guns are far ahead of other options. ☝️
R
JM springs are very good about maintaining consistent velocity, without taking a sag after several thousand shots.
 
2

I think the alternative explanation is that airguns are somewhat of an old man’s hobby and that as many younger shooters age they will become more interested in airguns.

PCPs are definitely winning a big part of the airgun market at the expense of springers though.
My grandson after shooting all of my guns, picked the Beeman Webly Vulcan as his favorite. That was prior to the Weihrauch's or FX's, but included a Gauntlet2 and Beeman Cheif2, Benjamin, Sheridan's, and a Hatsan 95 QE.

Before he actually spent time with all of them his favorite was the Gauntlet2, hands down, but it was the Vulcan in the end.

If you seniors want them to see them shoot a springer, get one in their hands.

20240607_212416.jpg
 
My grandson after shooting all of my guns, picked the Beeman Webly Vulcan as his favorite. That was prior to the Weihrauch's or FX's, but included a Gauntlet2 and Beeman Cheif2, Benjamin, Sheridan's, and a Hatsan 95 QE.

Before he actually spent time with all of them his favorite was the Gauntlet2, hands down, but it was the Vulcan in the end.

If you seniors want them to see them shoot a springer, get one in their hands.

View attachment 518168
My daughter really likes my R7. I’ve noticed she’s started referring to it as her gun.