.22 LR vs .22 slug

A note about 22LR ammo: if I had a dollar for every new 22LR precision or benchrest shooter and finds out you can’t just place an order for a $200 brick of ammo and shoot tiny groups, … well yeah … I could buy a brick of ammo.

Shooting very accurately with either system is expensive and challenging. With rimfire you are endlessly trying to keep good ammo coming and lot testing and sorting the best stuff from the rest. I have not had much experience with slugs but it seems like if you’re working from your own dies and you get it working, you have a much more manageable situation.
There’s more to it about match ammo, yes there are serious shooters that will travel just to lot test Eley and I don’t know about Lapua. There are those of us that rely on the name and buy bricks to get hopefully an upper hand on those that won’t spend the money. Even Tenex is the exact same ammo as Match sorted out by Eley. All in all it and Lapua Midas has always tested better than others for me. Then again a brick lasts me awhile.
 
  • Like
Reactions: honeysuckle
@WooblyHand You are correct in my missing JimD’s point and for that I am embarrassed. No one is perfect, we can only do our best. A selfish error on my part of being too focused on my own view point & caught up in the moment. An apology is in order! I am sincerely grateful for you gingerly pointing that out to me.
 
There’s more to it about match ammo, yes there are serious shooters that will travel just to lot test Eley and I don’t know about Lapua. There are those of us that rely on the name and buy bricks to get hopefully an upper hand on those that won’t spend the money. Even Tenex is the exact same ammo as Match sorted out by Eley. All in all it and Lapua Midas has always tested better than others for me. Then again a brick lasts me awhile.
Lapua test centers are in Mesa AZ and Marengo Ohio. I got into Marengo last year and I’m hoping again this year.

Whidden is now the Eley factory test center and they have the dedicated inventory of being an Eley factory test center. They also test Lapua when they have enough in stock to do it.

It’s tough. Most of my match ammo comes from buying a match ammo several bricks at a time and testing to figure out which ammo shoots beat with switch barrel in what conditions.

I guess that’s my point - while getting slugs fully dialed is often difficult, the highest end of 22LR is no picnic either.
 
Last edited:
I was certainly not in any way offended by other comments. I was just referring to how far a projectile will travel when I said propellent doesn't matter but I did not make that clear. I don't know all the reasons extreme spread and standard deviation tend to be higher for pbs but I accept priming as a big deal especially for rimfire.

I consistently learn from others comments.
 
Lapua test centers are in Mesa AZ and Marengo Ohio. I got into Marengo last year and I’m hoping again this year.

Whidden is now the Eley factory test center but they have the dedicated inventory of the factory test centers. They also test Lapua when they have enough

It’s tough. Most of my match ammo comes from buying a match ammo several bricks at a time and testing to figure out which ammo shoots beat with switch barrel in what conditions.

I guess that’s my point - while getting slugs fully dialed is often difficult, the highest end of 22LR is no picnic either.
You know way more than I do , only read about it. I did get 2 bricks of the same lot I used for our club bench. I haven’t shot in 5 years but hope to go back. Got 2 or 3 Midas bricks left also. I used most of both the Eley and Lapua for silhouette which could easily said a waste.
What’s your benchrest rimfires ? I think it’s time for dedicated one.
 
I shoot 50y benchrest locally with all Rimfire guys. Despite prevailing more times than not over the unlimited Rimfire rifles....there is nobody showing any interest in trading their Rimfire for air.

I would say that my entire setup including tanks, compressor, slug press, rest, gun, scope, etc to be around $15,000. A similarly scoring unlimited Rimfire shooters equipment outlay is probably around $8,000. You could reduce the cost of both considerably with an adequate scope vs a really nice scope. Either way the initial cash outlay is about double for air.

The Rimfire guys I compete with are spending 40-50c per shot for ammo. If you only shoot a match per month...that's not a huge deal ....maybe 75$ plus the cost of time to find ammo that actually shoots well in your gun. Not sure how to put a price on that. So a 1 match per month yearly cost is gonna be around $1000. Most of these guys shoot at least 3 matches per month....so now that's $3000 per year. It costs me 2c per slug if I use new lead wire. So 3 matches per month for me is $9. Yearly cost is a little over 100$.

At these rates it would take a little over 2 years to make up the difference in cost between the 2.

In actuality I shoot around 8000 slugs per month which costs me about 160$. Of course if I shot Rimfire at the same accuracy level....that same amount would cost around $4000. It's an easy return on investment in about 2 months over Rimfire.

The only conclusion that I can come to as why someone would choose unlimited Rimfire over unlimited air is that cost is not a factor for these individuals....or they simply don't shoot very much.

Mike
 
I think its worth mentioning that a 40gr pellet or 'slug' going 1085ft/s and has a BC of 0.112, will go (the 38 grain Heavy Slugs by H&N in 5.5 mm (.217) feature a ballistic coefficient of 0.112) are going to go the same distance with the same weight so really, stop with the whole "Miles Away" nonsense.
Please reread my post. Larger powder burning calibers can and do kill from miles away. It is foolish to fire bullets in to the air. 20 grain pellets are a whole different deal. Bullets can assume a trajectory, they do not simply fall to earth. Hi Velocity .22 rimfire is dangerous up to 1 1/4 miles away. Our .22 airguns can achieve similar power with slugs, be sure of your backstop before you pull the trigger, every projectile you launch. Ever have a .22 round whiz by your head from a long way away? One of my friends darn near shot me in the head as teenagers. He thought it would be funny to shoot over my head from a 1/2 mile away, he did not account for drop and darn near shot me in the head.
 
I have also shot 22lr in my cellar 13 yard range and eliminated a
few squirrels in the backyard with Aguila SSS it’s 60 g subsonic
and from memory was as quiet as my modified Revere 25. That’s
shot with my 1/4 moa 50 yard Sako Quad with Lilja barrel . $900
total less scope.
Im loving the Airguns but for any practical purpose they are inferior
and more expensive and would certainly not be grabbed in time of need
Then maybe you don't have the right air gun ?
 
Please reread my post. Larger powder burning calibers can and do kill from miles away. It is foolish to fire bullets in to the air. 20 grain pellets are a whole different deal. Bullets can assume a trajectory, they do not simply fall to earth. Hi Velocity .22 rimfire is dangerous up to 1 1/4 miles away. Our .22 airguns can achieve similar power with slugs, be sure of your backstop before you pull the trigger, every projectile you launch. Ever have a .22 round whiz by your head from a long way away? One of my friends darn near shot me in the head as teenagers. He thought it would be funny to shoot over my head from a 1/2 mile away, he did not account for drop and darn near shot me in the head.

I read your post, I addressed your comment about .22lr, I left the rest alone because it has nothing to do with airgunning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: honeysuckle
I read your post, I addressed your comment about .22lr, I left the rest alone because it has nothing to do with airgunning.
The power of airguns is approaching and exceeding powder based guns on a daily basis. When the projectiles are bullets (slugs) and the velocity is similar, the physics are also similar. When firing bullets, be certain of your backstop.
 
No way really can any but the most expensive air rifles hang with a good CZ or even my modded 1022 or Savage Target for accuracy much less fpe. And there are many, many .22LR rifles that will shoot MOA with preferred ammo, have far more knock down power for hunting and cost a fraction of an air rifle that could compete. As to ammo, I have stocked up on .22 ammo my entire life and would need another lifetime to shoot all I have. A .22 PB can go from 30 fpe to 150 fpe with a change of ammo. And a .22 PB is also half the weight of some of the air rifles I see on these forums. A .22 PB will also hold POI in rough real world use even for decades.

I justify my four modded .25 M-Rods and my Urban .22 because pellets just do not travel as far or keep energy as far nor do they seem a ricochet likely as .22LR. They have a niche for my pesting and hunting that is very useful in that 30 to 60 fpe range. They are no replacement for a good .22LR rifle.

This Savage was purchased for $350 with a $50 rebate back aways. I have done a lot of work on it. Re-crowned the barrel, bedded the action, installed DIP bottom metal, target trigger work, smoothed the action and it will shoot MOA all day long with CCI SV and with match grade ammo it is hole on hole.



But this super lightweight, short shroud, side lever M-Rod .25 will go hole on hole also, it is a mean hunting machine:



And on the subject, air rifles depreciate the day you buy it. PB rifles retain their value and even appreciate. I have owned this Marlin Mountie 39A my entire life. My grandfather bought it for me the day I was born. I have been shooting it since age 3, yes, really. It is good today as it was 70 years ago, tell me how an FX will fare over 70 years of real world hunting use, not so well I bet.



Do not make the mistake of thinking an air rifle is on par with a good .22 PB rifle, just no way for so many reasons.
Now you did say:
Do not make the mistake of thinking an air rifle is on par with a good .22 PB rifle, I think your wrong.
 
  • Like
Reactions: honeysuckle
Like many have said, I don't see an economic argument for an airgun if a 22LR suits your shooting needs. If you want to minimize your day-to-day expenses with an airgun your initial investment is going to be enormous -- air tanks and compressor. While for a powder burner the initial investment can be quite light, and day to day expenses is not much more than ammo and the occasional cleaning supplies. Maybe if you're shooting 200+ rounds a day over decades, the investment could make sense but I haven't done the computation.
 
No way really can any but the most expensive air rifles hang with a good CZ or even my modded 1022 or Savage Target for accuracy much less fpe. And there are many, many .22LR rifles that will shoot MOA with preferred ammo, have far more knock down power for hunting and cost a fraction of an air rifle that could compete. As to ammo, I have stocked up on .22 ammo my entire life and would need another lifetime to shoot all I have. A .22 PB can go from 30 fpe to 150 fpe with a change of ammo. And a .22 PB is also half the weight of some of the air rifles I see on these forums. A .22 PB will also hold POI in rough real world use even for decades.

I justify my four modded .25 M-Rods and my Urban .22 because pellets just do not travel as far or keep energy as far nor do they seem a ricochet likely as .22LR. They have a niche for my pesting and hunting that is very useful in that 30 to 60 fpe range. They are no replacement for a good .22LR rifle.

This Savage was purchased for $350 with a $50 rebate back aways. I have done a lot of work on it. Re-crowned the barrel, bedded the action, installed DIP bottom metal, target trigger work, smoothed the action and it will shoot MOA all day long with CCI SV and with match grade ammo it is hole on hole.



But this super lightweight, short shroud, side lever M-Rod .25 will go hole on hole also, it is a mean hunting machine:



And on the subject, air rifles depreciate the day you buy it. PB rifles retain their value and even appreciate. I have owned this Marlin Mountie 39A my entire life. My grandfather bought it for me the day I was born. I have been shooting it since age 3, yes, really. It is good today as it was 70 years ago, tell me how an FX will fare over 70 years of real world hunting use, not so well I bet.



Do not make the mistake of thinking an air rifle is on par with a good .22 PB rifle, just no way for so many reasons.
Did you say any air rifle? Meet the MCAR 45 cal it will outperform your good .22 in every way. Air guns have been around long before PB and there are some that can be fired today, may not be the oldest but older than your Marlin. It's all in how it's been maintained.
 
  • Like
Reactions: honeysuckle
I shoot 50y benchrest locally with all Rimfire guys. Despite prevailing more times than not over the unlimited Rimfire rifles....there is nobody showing any interest in trading their Rimfire for air.

I would say that my entire setup including tanks, compressor, slug press, rest, gun, scope, etc to be around $15,000. A similarly scoring unlimited Rimfire shooters equipment outlay is probably around $8,000. You could reduce the cost of both considerably with an adequate scope vs a really nice scope. Either way the initial cash outlay is about double for air.

The Rimfire guys I compete with are spending 40-50c per shot for ammo. If you only shoot a match per month...that's not a huge deal ....maybe 75$ plus the cost of time to find ammo that actually shoots well in your gun. Not sure how to put a price on that. So a 1 match per month yearly cost is gonna be around $1000. Most of these guys shoot at least 3 matches per month....so now that's $3000 per year. It costs me 2c per slug if I use new lead wire. So 3 matches per month for me is $9. Yearly cost is a little over 100$.

At these rates it would take a little over 2 years to make up the difference in cost between the 2.

In actuality I shoot around 8000 slugs per month which costs me about 160$. Of course if I shot Rimfire at the same accuracy level....that same amount would cost around $4000. It's an easy return on investment in about 2 months over Rimfire.

The only conclusion that I can come to as why someone would choose unlimited Rimfire over unlimited air is that cost is not a factor for these individuals....or they simply don't shoot very much.

Mike
Mike makes the best airguns in the world. I used to own one.
However, he is the only one in the world who makes an airgun system that can compete with an Unlimited RF rifle shooting first class ammo. And, even so, I don't know if Mike's system would be competitive at the ARA or PSL level.
I also believe that availability trumps price as a determining factor in choosing between an Unlimited RF rifle and an airgun. There are numerous quality gunsmiths that can assemble a competitive Unlimited rifle from readily available parts (except for Shilen Barrels) in a few months or less. Mike is the sole maker of Thomas airguns and the wait time reflects that reality.
The one true airgun advantage is ammo. RF rifles live and die on the vagaries of ammunition availability. With an airgun, once you find the perfect slug and secure a swage, you're home free.

I would really enjoy competing at ARA level with an airgun but I'm not sure I'll live that long.

JackHughs