FX Are expensive PCPs worth it?

Are highend guns worth it?

  • Yes.

  • Yes, but only for competition shooting.

  • Yes, but 2k is too much.

  • No.

  • No, but they are nice to have.

  • Never had a gun cost over a grand.


Results are only viewable after voting.
Here is my cat... only pcp I have and really enjoy it. 22 caliber with 500mm barrel

20240523_140842.jpg
 
OK, my response to the OP’s question: Are expensive PCPs worth it?

Answer: It is highly dependent on your Use Case for the rifle. Generally, I’d say they are not worth it. The law of diminishing returns certainly applies to PCPs.

Rationale for answer: If your use case is competition shooting and you require the highest accuracy and performance available, then an expensive PCP may be “worth it” to achieve your goals.

If your use case is backyard plinking or pesting or squirrel hunting, then the performance, accuracy and reliability of many modestly priced PCPs will be more than adequate.

Support for rationale: I must have 15+ “expensive“ PCPs (FX, Daystate, RTI, Taipan, Weihrauch, etc.). My 1st PCP was a .177 Umarex Gauntlet. I still have it. I paid $199 for it from Pyramyd Air.
I filled it with a $50 hand pump from eBay. I still have it. The regulator and hammer spring are NOT adjustable. It shoots inexpensive Crosman Premier 10.5g domes amazingly well. It has still never leaked. In 2023 I put a Sightron target scope on it one afternoon and shot consecutive Thirty Yard Challenge cards of 198, 196, 197 with the $199 rifle and Wal*Mart pellets. The 10-ring on the TYC target is .125” (1/8”) diameter.

How much more accurate is a PCP costing 10x more ($2,000) than my .177 Gauntlet going to be - and do you absolutely require higher performance? Very diminishing returns here...

Summary: Expensive items such as PCP air rifles, cameras, cell phones, watches, autos, etc are “worth it” if you get the level of enjoyment that you were hoping for… but they are often not “worth it” from a pure performance perspective.

Just the opinion of a guy who now has so many PCPs that he has lost count (truth).. but who is enjoying the heck out of them, lol - so “worth it” to me.

-Ed

View attachment 525262

View attachment 525263

View attachment 525264

1000073553.jpg


I'm not sure if that's your cheek sweat or you drooling all over your stock after you shot a good string. I would have had to immediately wipe that off my super-expensive laminate stock. So maybe it's not worth it? Nah! It's worth it.
😂
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: coastal drifter
A $2000 airgun is slightly better than a $500 air gun, all things being equal.
But all things are not equal !

A good shooter with a tuned $500 airgun will outshoot (accuracy wise) an average shooter with a $2000 airgun.
Good shooters tune their airguns.
Average shooters with expensive airguns expect their airguns to do the work for them

And by the way, enough wind will make your $2000 airgun shoot like a BB gun.
 
View attachment 525511

I'm not sure if that's your cheek sweat or you drooling all over your stock after you shot a good string. I would have had to immediately wipe that off my super-expensive laminate stock. So maybe it's not worth it? Nah! It's worth it.
😂

Nope, those are tears 😢 from the guy with the laminate stock that got beat by my lowly Gauntlet shooting $5 WalMart pellets, lol.
 
I've been looking at .30 cal to take down some of the yote population I hunt at along with other pests (groundhogs mostly). And I'm really on the fence about what gun to get. I'm really thinking of getting an FX Maverick VP, seems to fill in everything I would want. Short, great aftermarket support, slug shooter, isn't super heavy, accurate (from what I heard), and more then enough power for me. But the price is a lot to take. I'm really worried about buyer remorse.

I've had 3 PCP rifles now, all under a grand (Avenge-X, Notos, and an AEA Element Max). And I have been happy with them. Are +1k guns really worth it? For that matter are +2k guns worth it? You guys/gals that bought these higher end guns, do you feel you got your money worth?
I am new to PCP's and I bought a Maverick VP in .25 cal and absolutely love it! I had it set up to my specifications, so it was ready to shoot when I pulled it out of the box. I have been taking squirrels out easily at 40+yards. I don't think you would have buyer's remorse, it took me some time to pull the trigger on the purchase but glad I did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coastal drifter
A range of 1k to 2.5 k is a good and acceptable parameter.

Under 1k quality ismgoing to be poor.

Above 2.5 k probably you will be schemed.
This is nonsense. My biggest issues were on my 1 over $1k gun. My 5 under $500 guns have not collectively had as many issues. The one gun I have not changed the regulator on has been completely trouble free. If by quality you are strictly talking about machining quality you may have a point but the comment is either under informed or deliberately misleading. You are welcome to tell yourself or your wife this to justify your purchases but it is not true.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nobody1
I've never had any hobby that was cheap, so you accept that going in. Like anything else, things progress and just like benchrest shooting, it depends on how much money you spend who wins. We all have to decide where we fit in that scenero. There are good airguns at all levels. They will need some minor tuning or tweaking to be great, but nothing major. The Marauder and Avenger come to mind. Then you step up to even more powerful, tunable airguns like the Dreamline and guns like that. The next level is the top of the line guns. They have the great innovations like barrel swapping and dual regs or some such. But all of this is a decision you have to make. The best barrels, the best triggers, on and on.
Yes, they're worth it, no question in my mind. But i also reworked the trigger on my friends Avenger and the way it shot was amazing, it's hard to imagine more money making a big difference. I guess it's one of those things where you reach diminishing returns.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vana2
I've never had any hobby that was cheap, so you accept that going in. Like anything else, things progress and just like benchrest shooting, it depends on how much money you spend who wins. We all have to decide where we fit in that scenero. There are good airguns at all levels. They will need some minor tuning or tweaking to be great, but nothing major. The Marauder and Avenger come to mind. Then you step up to even more powerful, tunable airguns like the Dreamline and guns like that. The next level is the top of the line guns. They have the great innovations like barrel swapping and dual regs or some such. But all of this is a decision you have to make. The best barrels, the best triggers, on and on.
Yes, they're worth it, no question in my mind. But i also reworked the trigger on my friends Avenger and the way it shot was amazing, it's hard to imagine more money making a big difference. I guess it's one of those things where you reach diminishing returns.
I never said that a rifle under 1k would not shoot at all not that necesarly Wolf be unaccurate.

When you have a Daystate, a FX, a Vulcan (and many others) in your hands, you FEEL the quality!
 
This sounds like a personal choice but, to me it's a big NO. I am a hunter and sometime I do shoot targets out to 400 yards. It's not the gun/PCP that makes a good shot. Sure, they may be regulated or computer controlled so you can make that same exact shot but as a hunter all you need is one well-placed shot within your limit. Some of them if something goes wrong with them do you have to send back to the place of purchase or if you have a simple design 9 times out of ten you can if it your self.
 
  • Like
Reactions: L.Leon
A range of 1k to 2.5 k is a good and acceptable parameter.

Under 1k quality ismgoing to be poor.

Above 2.5 k probably you will be schemed.
Just to clarify:

A PCP under 1k can be as accurate and powerful as a very expensive one.

The quality of a Daystate, a Vulcan, a FX and many others that are above 1k, is something that you FEEL once you have in your hands.
 
well... I've competed VS all gammas of FX guns and Vulcans... yet I've managed to beat a lot of those high end rifles with my .22 Avenge-x...

I got 3 second places on benchrest so far... Trying to get a 1srt place...

View attachment 525814
The instrument matters, but the man using it matters more.

But wind wins against both.
 
This is a question that cannot be answered.

What is expensive? What is 'high end'? I just bought a Subaru Crosstrek. $32,000 was a lot of money for a car to me. Many others may consider it a cheap car. Is it high end? Compared to the Tacoma I had been driving for the past 25 years.... YUP even though it is an inexpensive vehicle by today's standards.

Subaru is now the most dependable car on the road. Mercedes isn't even in the top10, yet Mercedes is 'considered' by many to be high end. Those people have different standards than me.

Does price dictate quality/performance? Quality=Usually yes. Performance... not always. I will use Skout as an example. Skout sister company makes a high end paintball gun (Luxe) and a midrange gun (Shocker). Luxe is almost double the price of the Shocker... performance is basically the same.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vana2