I got my MTC Genesis back from AoA and since it is of similar specs to the Athlon Midas I was curious to how they are next to the other. Both are close in weight and length with each having a 50mm objective. The power range is almost the same: the Genesis at 5x-20x and Midas 2.5x to 15x. The Midas is about 100 dollars more (msrp, I looked and only paid $60 more for the Midas). Both of mine are MOA.
Optics: Midas is the clear winner offering a view of fine crisp details. I was looking at a mailbox 30 yards away through each one and the Genesis starting at 15 power shows it is not made with ED glass (but not crap by any means). The Midas has ED in parts or all of it and the numbers on the mailbox were sharper lacking the CA haze that the Genesis showed. Mind you on 12x or lower the Genesis looks very good and it is as bright as the Midas. And before I had the Midas I thought the Genesis was great in terms of clarity. But now the Midas wins that round.
Color: Both seem equal, displaying true to life, easy on the eyes color. Since the Athlon won in the optics it too wins here as there is almost no CA therefore no purple to speak of.
Eye relief: This one is tough. On lower powers the Midas holds out on 2.5 through 8x on exit pupil and therefore is easier and forgiving. Around 10x and up the Genesis still is at half power so edges out the Midas that is approching its max at 15x. Then at 15x I would say they are the same. Both though are so close and great for eyeglass users.
Range finding, Parallax:
The wheel on the Genesis has what feels like more accurate markings in practice. I didnt mount each one yet to test that aspect. Both would 'snap' into focus but not being a FT guy I dont know which would be better. 10 yards is the minimum on each.
I like the LED power switch on the Athlon better but if any want to know the Genesis has a higher brightness of the reticle for what it's worth. Less of it is illumunated only the very center, which may be less distracting for some.
I would say since the Athlon has open turrents, better glass type construction and an acceptable power range, that it edges out the slightly cheaper costing MTC Genesis. The reticles are similar at first glace but one would have to research which is better for their shooting.