If that's your biggest problem,......... personally, I think that's awesome group and shooting!!!
What caliber are you shooting, velocity, weight, type of barrel (smooth twist, straight barrel, choked barrel).
A VERY slight breeze, that you don't think is there, could easily scoot that pellet the 11/2", so I would look there. As I said, it don't take much.
Another possibility, is, the barrel might have to be indexed, much like benchrest shooters do. I don't know the entire process, but I do know that they will rotate the barrel until the group's end up higher or lower, (I forget which). If the group goes to the left or right, this is an undesirable effect, so they rotate the barrel so the group's are more vertical. This insures that the wind, when it is present, doesn't put the pellet farther than what they can predict.
Some guns' barrels cannot be rotated, due to the transfer port in the barrel, much like a Marauder.
If any seasoned benchrest guys see this post, they may be able to shed some light on this, or clarify some of the points I've made above.
Hope this helps,
Tom Holland
[email protected] Assistant Match Director
Eastern Suffolk Competitive Airgunners Association (ESCAA)Long Island NY escaaclub.com