Ethical Hunting with a Big Bore

[Michael]

Compliments of Pyramyd Air "Airgun Academy' blog




Ethical airgun hunting


by Tom Gaylord
Writing as B.B. Pelletier

Below is a discussion about how a big bore airgun kills game. If your interests are in smallbore airguns and appropriate game for those calibers, scroll to the end of this article for links to another article and a couple videos.

This will be a detailed discussion that may not be suitable for people who feel uncomfortable reading about or talking about killing animals.

What constitutes a big bore?

I’m asked this question all the time. What makes an airgun a big bore? I started answering this question before many others even knew what big bore airguns were, and I’ll continue to answer it in this same way. There are 4 common smallbore calibers — .177, .20, .22 and .25. Anything larger than a .25 is a big bore. Sounds simple, but it invites the barracks lawyers to chime in. There are airguns today that shoot .257-caliber conical bullets, and isn’t a .257 technically a .25? Yes, it is. This is where my simple definition breaks down a little.

But there’s more to it than that. A hundred fifty years ago, hunters had no difficulty understanding that a rifle that shot .40-caliber balls or larger was suitable for hunting whitetail deer. In a pinch, they would even use a .38-caliber rifle, but .40 caliber was the place they wanted to be for large, thin-skinned, non-dangerous game. You won’t find this written in any book that I know of; but if you read a lot of shooting history, it’ll come out.

So, the hunters of old knew that the bottom line for a rifle for larger game (the smallest you could use and expect success) was around .40 caliber. And .45 caliber was even better. When the ball got that large, there was no mistaking where things stood.

Then, conical bullets came along (1860?) and muddied up the water. Suddenly, a .32-caliber rifle shooting a heavy conical bullet (like the .32-40 in 1884) was sufficient for deer, but a .38 caliber shooting conicals (the .38-55, about the same time) was even better. And, just when that was being digested by the sporting public, smokeless powder came on the scene and bullet velocities doubled. At that point, .30-caliber rifles (like the .30-30) could take deer; and, soon, even .25-caliber rifles (such as the .25-35 Winchester) were considered marginal.

The one unified law

Many of today’s shooters don’t even know what a .25-35 Winchester cartridge is. Yet, they want one unified definition for a big bore airgun, but none exists. No single definition can be applied — especially, if the people applying it refuse to understand basic ballistics. If they think that the title “big bore” conveys some mystical killing power to any airgun, they’re sadly mistaken. Yes, I can tell you what a big bore airgun IS, but that, by itself, tells you very little about what it can DO. To know that, we have to understand how game is killed.

In the olden days, a .40-caliber ball was considered big enough to take deer — not because of its energy, which was almost nil, but because of its size. And projectile size is what I’m talking about here.

Respect for game

When I studied for my German hunting license in the 1970s while serving there in the U.S. Army, I learned how much the German hunters respect the game they kill. Besides learning a specialized vocabulary of German words that apply only to hunting and demonstrating proficiency with a rifle, we had to know how to treat game with respect. For example, whenever I killed a roe deer, I put a sprig of pine in its mouth as a ceremonial “last bite.”

Sure, such things are for the hunters and not for the game whose lives have already been taken, but what they do is remind the hunter that this was a living being that enjoyed life until the end. I think these small ceremonies keep most hunters from becoming crass. That has everything to do with this discussion.

Big bore airguns are very different

Most hunters are surprised when they shoot a game animal with a big bore airgun. They’re surprised because the animal doesn’t fall down at the shot. Typically, they stand for several minutes where they were hit . . . as they slowly expire (die) from blood loss. It’s so different from anything they may have experienced while hunting with modern firearms.

When a large game animal is hit with modern expanding bullets traveling at supersonic speeds, it can drop instantly in its tracks. Granted, that doesn’t happen often, but it does happen. At the very least, a well-hit animal that’s hit with a modern expanding bullet runs only a short distance before piling up. Thirty seconds is usually the longest you have to wait before it drops — when the animal has been hit well. Modern centerfire bullets have caused hunters to expect quick results that big bore airguns do not and cannot give.

Hunting with a big bore airgun is very similar to hunting with a muzzleloading rifle that shoots lead balls or bullets — not one shooting modern jacketed softpoints with sabots. It’s also similar to hunting with a bow. The game often stands in one place, looking around like it hasn’t been hit. Or if it does run, it runs fast and far and has to be tracked. The secret is to not follow the game right away. After the shot, wait about 10 minutes for the animal to stop running and start stiffening up. They’ll usually bed down at this point and won’t be able to get up again.

There are exceptions

Of course, there are exceptions to what I’m saying about modern bullets and game. I’ve had them happen to me — animals that appear to be hit well, but last much longer than they should. The hunting archives are full of stories about game that refused to die. But you have to recognize these for what they are — exceptions to what usually happens. In general, a modern bullet of the correct size and power will very quickly dispatch an animal that is hit well.

A big truth about big bore bullets

Here’s a truth that escapes many modern hunters. A .45-caliber lead bullet generating 250 foot-pounds of energy will kill a medium-sized animal such as a whitetail deer just as dead in the same amount of time as a .45-caliber lead bullet that generates 1,500 foot-pounds of energy. That’s because most of the more powerful bullet’s energy is not expended in the animal — it slips right through and keeps on going! Most of the energy is excess to your needs.

Unless there’s a large bone in the way, or the animal has a particularly tough hide, you don’t need to hit it with a lot of energy. These heavy lead bullets don’t kill with their energy — they kill with blood loss. This is why relatively light round balls kill large game so effectively.

New big bore hunters are fascinated with hollowpoint lead bullets — thinking that the expansion of the bullet inside game transfers more of the bullet’s energy to the animal. But it isn’t the energy that kills — it’s the loss of blood. So, a .45-caliber solid bullet kills just as fast as a hollowpoint bullet that mushrooms out to .75 caliber. Once the hole in the animal is big enough, it doesn’t make much difference if it grows any larger. The damage has been done.

What I’m leading up to is this: A 405-grain .458-caliber bullet is fine for the largest game. If I think I need it to penetrate a heavy bone or a thicker hide, the 405 is the way to go. But if I’m hunting thin-skinned whitetails or something similar (javelinas, coyotes, mountain lions, etc.), I want a much lighter bullet that has the advantage of a flatter trajectory.

The 405-grain bullet would be perfect for American elk (wapiti), red deer and bison. We know from actual field experience that it will pass completely through even these massive animals when it impacts on one side, such as with a classic heart/lung shot. That happens even when the bullet is fired from a 500 foot-pound rifle. Then, the process of bleedout begins and the animal drops several minutes later, when blood loss has its effect. This is something archers understand all too well. But many who come into big bore airguns from the firearm side are used to hydrostatic shock.

Hydrostatic shock

Hydrostatic shock is the shock wave that passes through the liquid-filled tissues of an animal when hit by an ultra-high-velocity bullet. This shock wave is devastating to the animal’s nervous system and can sometimes cause near-immediate death. Many hunters are so accustomed to this effect that they cringe when they see how long it takes a bullet from a primitive rifle or an arrow to drop an animal. That slow performance is exactly what you can expect from a big bore airgun bullet.

Why you need to know this

Many people would like to learn to hunt, and big bore airguns are starting to look like an easy way into the sport. That’s fine — as long as you know what you’re getting into. At the end of your hunt, an animal is going to die and it’s going to take a long time to do it — especially if you’ve hunted only with modern centerfire rifles, or the only hunting you’ve ever seen is what’s on television.

Believe me, the hunting shown on television is heavily edited! If the game happens to drop instantly when shot, they show it — but if not, they edit in some tracking, along with conversation to get your mind off what’s really happening. If it takes 12 minutes for an animal to die, you will only see about 20-30 seconds of that. I happen to agree with that approach, because people don’t need to see the suffering in their living rooms.

But, if you decide to go out into the field to hunt, then I want you to know what you’re going to see. I hunted extensively when I was younger, and everything I’ve described here I’ve seen many times over. But I’ve also seen a first-time hunter confronted by the truth. And he was shocked. That wasn’t pleasant.

Just understand that when you do decide to hunt with a big bore, the results will probably look a lot different than you might have imagined.

Other airgun hunting resources

If you’re interested in hunting with smallbore airgun calibers, read [url="https://www.pyramydair.com/article/Airgun_Hunting_April_2012/83"]Hunting with airguns, a general article that touches on the common types of pests and game usually taken with .177- to .25-caliber airguns.

 

[JW652]

Five stars. Thank you.

Many folks do not realize that their .22 cal. air rifle producing 60 fpe is only about 2/3 as powerful as a .22 short. Would a .22 short be your choice to ethically harvest a ground hog?

Also, a lot of people equate an airgun to a black powder rifle and think we shouldn't have to worry about Federal regulation. But with the advent of semi and full auto air rifles, we have opened another door - that the government can close on us. Just ask our Brit cousins.

Airgun ownership brings with it moral and legal responsibilities. Thank you for reminding us.

 

[sef5359]

Anybody have a big bore Winchester model 70 45 or 70/357. I was thinking about getting one want to know what you think of it thank you

 

[sonny]

I agree about respecting the animals we kill whether we kill then for harvest/eating or we call them pests we should still have respect for the life's we are taking. 

 

[fuznut]

Hands down the best post i have ever seen on any air gun fourm. How did i not see this before? Thank you Michael for takeing the time. 900 views 3 positive responses is a good example of why we need more like it.

 

[Gettsgunner]

Thanks for sharing this Michael. 

 

[wilbowling]

Great post, Im looking for a .375 for an all around hunter for small to med lg game.

 

[Asher]

I would add that like archery, it's best to take shots as close to the animal as possible. Unless you're shooting a very powerful big bore or a very light projectile, or both, your shots are probably not supersonic. Thus, it's possible for the animal to hear the shot before it is hit by the shot, and the further away the animal is, the more time it will have to react to the sound, potentially causing you to miss completely or even worse, hit the animal where you werent aiming.

 

[Biren]

Nice Very informative post. Cleared many doubts.

Thanks & Regards

Biren

 

[AncientSword]

Five stars. Thank you.

Many folks do not realize that their .22 cal. air rifle producing 60 fpe is only about 2/3 as powerful as a .22 short. Would a .22 short be your choice to ethically harvest a ground hog?

Also, a lot of people equate an airgun to a black powder rifle and think we shouldn't have to worry about Federal regulation. But with the advent of semi and full auto air rifles, we have opened another door - that the government can close on us. Just ask our Brit cousins.

Airgun ownership brings with it moral and legal responsibilities. Thank you for reminding us.

A .22 short shows up as 50 fpe when I look it up. Maybe you meant .22 LR? I know I’d rather use a high power pcp in .22 or a .25 than a .22 short. 

 

[takesittoofar]

Damn good read. 

 

[jmmoore2]

Wow great post

 

[RayAnderson2244]

Very helpful

 

[ACTORDARRYLSMALL]

gosh dittos about this being a good read, but do you write anything else,?
because i could read more of your stuff Brother 

 

[TSchmidt]

Insightful. Thank you.

 

[Markkomoroski]

I have 2 airforce 357ss if anyone is interested 

 

[durbs75]

Some states laws are loosely written. I’m thankful for the opportunity to use air rifles in my state but they should be written more precisely.

 

[Milehighguy]

Good article. 

I think someone else was going down this path but I thought I'd chime in. For airguns throwing bullets at under 900 FPS time to target becomes a factor. Generally speaking, a deer can react to sound in about .18 of a second or less. So, when you pull the trigger sound is traveling at 1035 (+/-) and reaches the game while the bullet / slug / pellet is traveling 100 FPS or more slower. The cumulative effect of distance compounds the issue as the bullet / slug / pellets slow. This being the case you want to hunt at a distance where your time to target is roughly .15 seconds or lower. In most cases with a bullet / slug / pellet traveling at 875 FPS the goal distance is 25 to 30 yards.

 

[creed]

Good read

 

[LRair]

Shot placement ...period. That applies to every and all forms of hunting.
Stalk or stand to be close enough, and have the discipline to hold the shot until you can double lung the game, and you will have success in an ethical manner.
Discussions on expansion, hydrostatic shock, wound channels, downrange ballistic performance may be part of the prep, but none as critical as placement of the projectile