Hawke Air Max 2-7x32 or 3-9x40 around $220 or so. The 2-7 weighs only 16oz. There is a guy on YouTube called Cyclops who reviews scopes. Look him up and watch some of what he does and how he checks scopes. He really liked the 2-7x32. I don’t have any experience with the Hawke Air Max but hear they are durable. My 4x Hawke Vantage is mounted on a Bulls Eye ZR recoil absorbing mount and should last forever so mounted.
I’m like you most of my shooting is under 40, actually I target shoot at 10 and 20 yds. In my yard 30yd shot is a long one on squirrel. Two of my scopes are 4x fixed, and an Athlon Talos 3-12x40. The Talos is set at 6x on my only PCP and it stays there. I’ve been through several variable power scopes but all are set at 6x and left there. So I went with fixed power on my my last 2 purchases. Fixed power scopes are lighter, have fewer parts to go wrong, less glass so brighter for equivalent price points.
The broken crosshairs can be a problem with any scope with wire crosshairs. There are many brands that have glass etched crosshairs which won’t break.
You have a 2-7x Vortex, what power do you shoot with mostly. I would look for a good fixed power scope in that power. Make sure they are springer rated, and have a good reputation for customer service repair or replace.
If you target shoot only look for a 10x, if you target shoot and pest control with it 4x or 6x will give a bigger field of view than the 10x.