I am far from an expert on all this, but I can tell you that the consistency of the grease I use is close, if not a little bit more "liquid" or lower viscosity than what I found in my grease pot when I got my CS4. But it IS NLGI 2 and very close to what I found in the pot originally. Also, since vegetable oil is combustible just like petroleum oil, I would stay away from that for that reason alone.
Not to mention that vegetable oil thickens and gets stiff over time. So I will stick with silicone based grease. It is what is recommended in 99.999999% of the case when it comes to HPA and airguns. Silicone doesn't degrade in such a fashion, AFAIK, and does not combust.
As I said, I am no expert, but I have been reading about this stuff for several years, so I hope I have gleaned the correct info. (grin)
All my best!
Kerry
p.s.
I wish all airguns had a standardized foster fitting instead of a non-standardized fill "probe"! LOL!
All my best!
Kerry