The question might be better asked for each of Four price points:
Very few air rifles will shoot out of the box without minor barrel lapping and deburring, and a little tuning and trigger work.
Again, this is assuming that the gun fits the competitor equally in their most stable position... which is not a safe expectation. Adjustability is a key point in my opinion.
$3,000 to $4,000,
Mike, with his Thomas is the only manufacture I know of, that test proves every gun before it leaves his shop. He wins the highest price point category, in my opinion.. Daystate Red wolf probably a close second. I don't like the FX impacts.. they have way too many parts that can fail, don't hold a tune, and are super hard to tune for accuracy.... in my opinion. We have had three Impacts with those difficulties, one for sale now for $1,200 if you are interested. (over $3,000 invested)
$2,000 to $2,900,
In the second price point, USFT, and RAW would lead the list for me. I used a non regulated low pressure fill (1,300psi) USFT tube gun to win the AAFTA GP this year with two 100% highest scores for the match, one 99% of high score and one 97% of high score, besting some Daystate Redwolfs and Thomas's in the process. Wind reading is way more important than the accuracy of your equipment, although in my opinion a USFT or RAW can be as accurate as the Red Wolf or Thomas. The USFT has the largest and strongest barrel block of all, for a "free floated barrel", even larger than Mikes Thomas.
Styers are famous for reg issues at the worst time during a key match.... be careful there.
$1,200 to $1.900
A used USFT or Raw wins again here for me..
Jefferson State Air Rifles is making quality air rifles again as well just getting in under this price limit for a new gun.
and $1,000 and under.
With a little barrel polishing the Kral line wins here. We like the Pro 500 for under $700. Benjamin puts their name on a line of Krals and ups the price for the effort. They also make the Marauder that deserves to be here too.
The 25 cal Gunner is a great gun for the Extreme FT and Benchrest games for the money... just at the $1,000 price point, but it needs a replacement barrel from Kral, but that's easy to install and costs about $70. We have upgraded several now that preform as well as anything we have shot in the 50fpe range at 100 yards.
But, again, it's not wise to buy without trying for fit in YOUR most stable shooting position... and you probably don't even know what that is until you come play and watch others, then try what seems like the best class and position for you.
That's the service we provide here in Ashland, Or. airgunoregon.com
Wayne
AirGun Oregon