cstar,
I don't have any experience with the Barska products, only the AT3. I don't understand why the AT3 doesn't get more "forum love" from other shooters. It's a great little sight with a great warranty and it's priced right. Oh well, just my opinion, different strokes I guess?
I thought maybe I should clarify a little bit about my magnification comments. When I'm shooting silhouettes at distances up to about 20 yards I can focus in on them pretty well and have no problem at all with a red dot or open sights.
It's when I'm attempting to shoot at 1" or 2" orange or green paper stick on targets and 1" (25 Meter air rifle benchrest) paper sheet targets or, well, any paper targets with scoring rings or markings on them that are in the 1" thru 3" size that I run into problems. Targets that small are just a blur to me once I get much past 10 meters. Hence my quest for some magnification assistance.
I've shot the pistol with the UTG scope on it a little bit. Holy Cow is it heavy! But the glass is clear, the reticle is very thin (a good thing to me) and I like it so far. Maybe I just need to pump a little iron and whip myself into better shape for tackling this, LOL!
Loading up the guns and heading to the range tomorrow myself. Hope you have fun Sunday!