I have found a simple hollow can to be very effective in some cases, like you were saying, not that much different from a moderator with stuff on the inside, especially if the gun has an air stripper or some space in the shroud.These really do look sweet, and look like they are upping their internals game. People can say what they want about paying for looks, but I’ve come to the conclusion that you might as well pay for looks when it comes to moderators.
I have tried a bunch of moderators, from just the old hollow can on the Impact to fancy internals like there are on STO, and many times the sound difference between them so was negligible, it didn’t matter what I used. I liked the hollow can on an old Impact more than I liked ones made from 3 or 4 popular manufacturers. More often, accuracy choice has won out. People get on here and ask where is your sound test, but I haven’t found a sound test to be necessary in any comparison I’ve done to choose which I like better. The loudness, has been so close, it has never been a deciding factor. (Each user has their own needs.) I usually just tell people now to get the one they like the looks best on or the one that is most consistent.
And?I got my hands on one. It's seriously next level. I can't wait to test it out. I just need to figure out which gun is most worthy of this thing!
View attachment 380762
been shooting tons of competitions lately. Haven't had time to test it out but it is currently on my Impact. I'll test it out shortlyAnd?
Puffers is what they are or is it pooters or phffffts?We could call them a brick.... and guess what people will still understand what they are. You guys are arguing semantics and nothing more. Don't like the wording then call it what you want and get over it.
Perhaps a forum member with legal resources can find the case summary to show us the details, of the chargesI'm curious about something. If he's not selling in the US because of the heat from the feds, how can a person even purchase one in the US and if they do, not worry about the alphabet people kicking their door in?
Don't be a "Word Policeman"... Not your job. Not in your job description...Nice write up. In the future, please refrain from using the misnomer "Silencer", stick with the terminology that DonnyFL and many other manufacturers use "Moderator"!
I agree, with what others have stated, the color mismatch between the base and modules is visually unpleasant.
Reasonable but the reason vendors don't do sound tests is really quite simple. They don't want you to know exactly what their moderators are doing. They don't want to have to explain to you what all that terminology means. They don't design for silencing. If it silences a little then it's in the ball park with the rest of the designs which really don't work. Find a moderator that really does work, something like a Huma, or a Weirauch and compare it to the subject moderator. You will immediately hear the difference.These really do look sweet, and look like they are upping their internals game. People can say what they want about paying for looks, but I’ve come to the conclusion that you might as well pay for looks when it comes to moderators.
I have tried a bunch of moderators, from just the old hollow can on the Impact to fancy internals like there are on STO, and many times the sound difference between them so was negligible, it didn’t matter what I used. I liked the hollow can on an old Impact more than I liked ones made from 3 or 4 popular manufacturers. More often, accuracy choice has won out. People get on here and ask where is your sound test, but I haven’t found a sound test to be necessary in any comparison I’ve done to choose which I like better. The loudness, has been so close, it has never been a deciding factor. (Each user has their own needs.) I usually just tell people now to get the one they like the looks best on or the one that is most consistent.
It is a good point as far as it goes. A problem with using a dB meter and not a "spectrum analyzer" (which you can download for your phone BTW) it that ALL dB meters, no matter what they cost, either average or calculate the RMS value of the various frequencies over some unknown (to you) period of time. There is no industry standard that defines the length of that time and it has an enormous influence on the measurement you get.Over the years I have tried to measure about ten moderators with a sound level meter, both cone-based (Wolf Airguns) and cages with sound-absorbing material (Weihrauch, Hugget, Huma etc.). The cone-based ones (like these two) lower the noise by a few decibels on the AC, unlike the others. Why should these be better? If someone shows us the test with a sound level meter then we can evaluate it better. Thanks
Bull hockey. Don't be the "Word Police", not your job. Not in your job description. The moderators and the forum owner decide which words to ban, not you, not me. They also decide what pictures to allow, what things can be discussed and how we have to behave, not you, not me.When I first joined airgun forums, both GTA and here, it was a no no to call a moderator anything else, especially the S word. Moderators would come on and if you were lucky you got a warning, if not, the thread got locked out.
Two words were allowed- moderator and an LDC.
We all used to police ourselves and especially others not in the know. Please don’t come down on Richieg as he’s doing exactly what we were all suppose to do back in the day.
Seems with the mass amount of PB folks coming into the airgun community as of the last couple of years that rule hasn’t been policed as it should.
If we don’t stay strict to keeping things about all Airguns then before long topics on reloading get brought up, pics of sniper rifles or long range creedmoores get shown, then one day our classifieds section has powder burner parts getting bought n sold.
He isnt. Those that keep using silencer will do so around the unknowing public and before too long we will catch the wrath and infringements that we dont want. We had a clueless manufacturer here calling them that and I called them out for it. Besides silencers are a misnomer and even for firearms they are an incorrect term.Don't be a "Word Policeman"... Not your job. Not in your job description...