What should i do for a finish?

Getting close to putting a finish on my 3622, and want some opinions. There are a couple filler spots that would be visible if left in a stain/oil finish, and this wood didn't like tru oil when I tried it, so that out.

I'm thinking of trying a hydro dip film or just sponge camo, but I've done a couple of those and I'd like to try something different.

1000007483.jpg
1000007482.jpg
 
That come along nicely.....Those water stains were quite deep?

I'd try a dark stain, you may have to do it in layers letting each coat dry completely.
I hit it with an orbital sander with 60 grit to knock down all the carve marks and bad water stains, then hand sanded with 80-180 so far. Some water stains are still visible.

I'm going to fill the inlet gaps this weekend and then maybe just do a flat or matte black over it til I figure out what I'm doing. It won't take oil, just turned it brown and hid the grain, and I'm afraid to try a stain because the wood is so dry it might soak it up and make it hard to remove if I don't like it.
 
Joedirt199 got me to dig this up......Of course you don't have the flat surface area but wouldn't be hard to improvise.

I had a quilted flame top Jackson super strat I sold a few years ago. It was a honey blonde, pretty guitar, I just moved on to thicker necks with a c profile since my hands have aged.
 
Getting close to putting a finish on my 3622, and want some opinions. There are a couple filler spots that would be visible if left in a stain/oil finish, and this wood didn't like tru oil when I tried it, so that out.

I'm thinking of trying a hydro dip film or just sponge camo, but I've done a couple of those and I'd like to try something different.

View attachment 463214View attachment 463215
Might I suggest dye…most can be cut with alcohol, and applied with a Preval spray unit. Lighter areas can be toned to match darker areas. Applied in light coats…a very uniform color can be achieved without masking the grain…good luck! John
 
Me, I like the classic low luster hand rubbed walnut look. I've refinished several older gunstocks and also one new semi-inletted sort of fancy stock I bought for a Handi Rifle.

My standard technique is hand sand per the advice above and start with multiple applications of Old English scratch cover for walnut (Wally has it). It's got oil & stain and fills in the grain very nicely. Rub in a coat, let it dry, repeat until the grain's filled or the color's to your liking. First few coats I just use a rag, later coats I use progressively finer steel wool. I use Tru Oil very sparingly for a few coats, rubbed out with fine or extra fine steel wool to get a durable finish that's not too Tru Oil-y looking.

I has used low luster/flat finish polyurethane on 2 guns but only a coat or two, and I rub the heck out those coats with steel wool, again to keep it low key.

I'll take picture or two if I can remember the gun safe combination . . .

Good luck! Scott