Thanks again for the answers. I think I finally understand what's going on. My goal is accuracy and maximum number of consistent shots, not fps. If I decreased regulator pressure to 1500 psi, what is the chance that I can get on the right side of the curve (knee) so that tuning the hammer spring will make sense?
You need to increase, not decrease regulator pressure. That way you will begin to enter the knee of the power curve versus the plateau which is where you are currently. Lowering will make matters worse, unless you re-spring the gun, which is the other option if you wanted to run lower reg pressure for more shot count.
As you increase pressure, the valve becomes harder to open, making the hammer work more, thus allowing the HST adjustment to work properly, lowering your pressure makes the valve easier to open.
Definitely not a good 'beginners' user experience based on what you're saying, no one should have to re-spring their gun to get an adjustment working as intended.
Lets say hypothetically your current spring is 10 lb/in, you would be best suited finding a spring of similar dimensions that were 8 or 9 lb/in instead, if you wanted to keep the 2,000 psi set point or take it below towards 1,500 psi it in its current state.
Ideally one tunes for the lowest reg pressure they can while achieving 103%~ of their desired power level, that way you can reduce the hammer strike a hair, and be at the 'knee' of your power curve, which is best for shot count/efficiency and lowered muzzle report. HTH
-Matt