Does pellet testing make sense?
- By Vana2
- General Discussion
- 39 Replies
We're seeing new brands and models of pellets being offered these days which is is great. Competition and choice is always good.
I've seen a couple of videos/blogs where people are evaluating and testing these new pellets in their "known to be accurate" airguns.
This doesn't make sense to me as the airgun is the biggest variable.
If we have a non-adjustable airgun we go through the process of finding the "golden pellet" that is most compatible with that particular airguns' factory tune and harmonics. Sometimes slightly different manufacturing tolerances will even cause airguns off the same production line to prefer different pellets.
With tunable airguns we can adjust the power to get excellent performance with a particular pellet.
Some airguns are less "pellet picky" than others but in both cases (fixed or tunable) we can't randomly choose a pellet and expect it to perform well.
So what is the purpose/value in "testing" pellets? The new pellet being evaluated may or may not be compatible with that particular airgun through no fault of the pellet's design or manufacture.
I think that you can check a pellet's quality to see if it's consistent in weight and size and inspect it for imperfections and cleanliness but you can't "test" it because the testing is only valid for that particular airgun.
Seems to me that the caveat "your milage may vary" strongly applies to pellet testing.
Don't know, am I missing something obvious?
Cheers!
I've seen a couple of videos/blogs where people are evaluating and testing these new pellets in their "known to be accurate" airguns.
This doesn't make sense to me as the airgun is the biggest variable.
If we have a non-adjustable airgun we go through the process of finding the "golden pellet" that is most compatible with that particular airguns' factory tune and harmonics. Sometimes slightly different manufacturing tolerances will even cause airguns off the same production line to prefer different pellets.
With tunable airguns we can adjust the power to get excellent performance with a particular pellet.
Some airguns are less "pellet picky" than others but in both cases (fixed or tunable) we can't randomly choose a pellet and expect it to perform well.
So what is the purpose/value in "testing" pellets? The new pellet being evaluated may or may not be compatible with that particular airgun through no fault of the pellet's design or manufacture.
I think that you can check a pellet's quality to see if it's consistent in weight and size and inspect it for imperfections and cleanliness but you can't "test" it because the testing is only valid for that particular airgun.
Seems to me that the caveat "your milage may vary" strongly applies to pellet testing.
Don't know, am I missing something obvious?
Cheers!